Week 6 Reading Response-Historical and Contemporary Realism

 Marshall III, Joseph. In The Footsteps of Crazy Horse. Amulet Books, 2015. ISBN: 978-1419707858

 In the Footsteps of Crazy Horse by Joseph Marshall III, one encounters a narrative that seamlessly intertwines historical and contemporary perspectives. Through the journey of Jimmy McClean, a young Lakota boy, the story connects past issues to present realities, making historical events relevant to today’s readers. Marshall III examines the 'why' of these events, particularly the life and legacy of Crazy Horse, offering rich opportunities for adult discussions about cultural heritage, identity, and resilience. The plot reflects the pace of life in both historical and contemporary periods, with historical episodes portrayed with an authentic sense of urgency and significance. Jimmy’s contemporary journey mirrors the challenges faced by Native Americans during Crazy Horse's era, making the narrative both engaging and relevant.

The settings in In the Footsteps of Crazy Horse are not just depicted but brought to life with historical, geographical, and political accuracy. This accuracy provides readers with a vivid sense of place that is both accurate and immersive. The characters, including Crazy Horse and Jimmy McClean, are not just names on a page but individuals with mannerisms, speech, dress, and attitudes reflective of their respective periods, adding to the authenticity of the story and making the reader feel as if they are right there, experiencing it all. The narrative style effectively conveys life in different periods, and the balance between narration and dialogue is well-maintained, making the story accessible and engaging. The language is conversational, enriched with figurative language and literary devices that enhance the storytelling.

In the Footsteps of Crazy Horse is not just a story but a mirror reflecting our struggles and triumphs. It presents positive cultural representation, avoiding stereotypes and tokenism and offering a nuanced portrayal of Native American culture. It logically progresses, preparing readers for the cause and effect of its events, offering universal implications for readers across different contexts. This book is not just a journey that resonates personally with readers, touching on issues of identity, cultural pride, and resilience that are universal and timeless. Its relevance to contemporary issues is a testament to its enduring value.

Woodson, Jacqueline. Before the Ever After. Nancy Paulsen Books, 2020. ISBN: 978-0399545443


 In Before the Ever After, Jacqueline Woodson introduces us to ZJ, a protagonist dealing with his father's deteriorating health due to CTE (Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy). The story portrays ZJ's love for his father and his confusion and sadness. ZJ's friends bring their unique personalities and coping mechanisms, creating a realistic picture of young adolescent experiences. The story takes readers on an emotional journey, exploring the impact of CTE on a family. Woodson's careful guidance through the emotional highs and lows keeps the reader engaged. The conclusion, while inevitable, remains unpredictable in how ZJ and his family will cope, maintaining a gripping tension until the end. The book's setting sharply contrasts with the challenges the characters face, influencing their actions and the development of the theme. The universal themes of love, loss, and resilience resonate with readers from diverse backgrounds. Woodson's language is conversational and accessible to young readers. The first-person point of view allows readers to feel ZJ's emotions intimately. The book's poignant yet hopeful tone and impactful chapter titles add an extra layer of engagement.

Woodson avoids cultural stereotypes and tokenism, offering a rich, authentic depiction of an African American family. The characters of color are fully developed, each with strengths, weaknesses, and complexities. The representation is positive and multifaceted, avoiding the pitfalls of cultural overloading or romanticism. Before the Ever After is a beautifully crafted novel that tackles difficult themes with sensitivity and insight, making it a standout for readers of all ages.

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week2-Reading Response 1-Board Books

Image
  Franceschelli, Christopher.  Alphablock . Illustrations by Peskimo. Abrams Appleseed; ISBN 9781419709364 (media-amazon.com) The book "Alphablock" by Christopher Franceschelli makes learning the alphabet more fun by incorporating die-cut shape flaps into its pages. These flaps engage children as they guess what each letter represents. The illustrations provide clues about the item each letter stands for and enhance the book's overall content. The artist skillfully uses texture in the photos to convey movement, such as the boat on the water or the kite flying in the air. This book captivates young readers with its expressive colors, delightful illustrations, and interactive flaps, ensuring that children remain engrossed as they explore the alphabet.   (media-amazon.com) DiCicco, Sue. 1, 2, 3 in the Sea. Scholastic Inc.; ISBN 9780545432382 1, 2, 3 in the Sea is a delightful counting book centered around the ocean theme. Readers will enjoy counting along while expl
Read more

Week 2 Reading Response 2-Picture Books

Image
  Lyons, Kelly Starling. Going Down Home with Daddy . Illustrated by Daniel Minter, Peachtree Publishing Company, 2019. ISBN 9781561459384 Going Down Home with Daddy tells the story of a family's trip to their ancestral home for a reunion. Daniel Minter's illustrations effectively capture the mood of the story. Minter uses colors to convey the time of day, the connection to the farm, and the emotions portrayed in the story. The illustrations don't conflict with the text; they complement it by adding depth to the words. This helps the reader understand the family’s history and tradition. Minter uses blues, greens, and browns to evoke an earthly feeling appropriate for a story about a family, farm, and heritage. The colors complement the lines of the drawings and highlight details, such as the white cotton being shown in the clothing throughout, tying it to the crops they grow on their land. The elements in the illustrations are arranged to guide the reader’s eye through
Read more

Week 3-Reading Response 1: Traditional Literature

Image
Grimm, J., Grimm, W., Segal, Lore.  The Juniper Tree, and Other Tales From Grimm . Translator Randall Jarrell. Doubleday Canada, Ltd., 1973.  ISBN: 978-0374180577 The Juniper Tree and Other Tales from Grimm is a collection of Grimm’s fairy tales translated by Lore Segal to maintain the original tone and themes of the stories. Segal preserves the dark tone of the original narratives while making them more accessible to readers. At the beginning of the book, there is a "note on the translations" that explains some of the translations included in the book. He thanks Paul Stern for assisting with the German translations, allowing Segal to keep the stories as authentic as possible. Segal stays true to the storytelling style by writing the translations in a narrative format. While reading the text, you can almost feel as if someone is telling the story to you, which makes the stories engaging for both children and adults. The format is suitable for reading the stories aloud or i
Read more